Volunteer Tourism

Schluzy, Katja

Volunteer Tourism

The Field for Product Innovations and a Platform for new Alliances for Sustainable Development in Tourism

von Katja Schluzy (Autor:in)

Tourismus - Sonstiges

Zusammenfassung

Inhaltsangabe:Introduction:
Voluntouring programs are incredible journeys through remarkable destinations, combining unique travel opportunities with meaningful volunteer work.
This statement, taken from the website of Aquila Tours, which is one of the first Canadian tour operators offering this kind of volunteer tourism, shows how this type of tourism is advertised and sold to the customer as a new kind of travel experience. This example illustrates how tour operators describe this kind of tourist experience using word games like Voluntouring in order to market this special form of tourism which combines leisure, volunteer work and travel. This way of spending meaningful holidays is gaining more and more popularity among vastly different demographic categories of people. To make a difference while on vacation is already very popular in the U.S, UK and Australia, but is also a concept that is getting more and more attention worldwide. The media has played an important role: from The Time Magazine to Forbes Magazine: articles have been devoted to the idea of blending tourism with community and environmental oriented work. Lonely Planet published its first volunteer-travel guidebook in June 2007 called Volunteer: A Travelers Guide to Making a Difference around the World as reaction to the growing importance of this travel segment.
Newsweek International stated in its article: Having fun doing good: For some altruistic travelers vacation means more than just a day at the beach, furthermore describing the phenomenon as follows: Its tourism with a conscience, undertaken by travelers who dont want to experience another culture through the windows of a tour bus (...). People are prepared to pay to volunteer and they are even willing to devote holiday time in order to get actively involved and help in environmental conservation projects as well as social projects. In Germany, this new type of travel is slowly beginning to be considered as an emerging trend and was recognised by the press as early as end of 2006 and has been considerably strengthened since the end of 2007. This phenomenon of combining holidays with volunteer work has even developed a new term integrating both aspects: Voluntourism. In addition, it has created an industry around this, the so-called Voluntourism Industry.
The numbers of socially responsible tourists as well as the opportunities available to them are increasing. The desire to help is matched by an […]

Leseprobe

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Katja Schluzy

Volunteer Tourism

The Field for Product Innovations and a Platform for new Alliances for Sustainable

Development in Tourism

ISBN: 978-3-8428-1077-8

Herstellung: Diplomica® Verlag GmbH, Hamburg, 2011

Zugl. Fachhochschule Eberswalde, Eberswalde, Deutschland, MA-Thesis / Master, 2008

Dieses Werk ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Die dadurch begründeten Rechte,

insbesondere die der Übersetzung, des Nachdrucks, des Vortrags, der Entnahme von

Abbildungen und Tabellen, der Funksendung, der Mikroverfilmung oder der

Vervielfältigung auf anderen Wegen und der Speicherung in Datenverarbeitungsanlagen,

bleiben, auch bei nur auszugsweiser Verwertung, vorbehalten. Eine Vervielfältigung

dieses Werkes oder von Teilen dieses Werkes ist auch im Einzelfall nur in den Grenzen

der gesetzlichen Bestimmungen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes der Bundesrepublik

Deutschland in der jeweils geltenden Fassung zulässig. Sie ist grundsätzlich

vergütungspflichtig. Zuwiderhandlungen unterliegen den Strafbestimmungen des

Urheberrechtes.

Die Wiedergabe von Gebrauchsnamen, Handelsnamen, Warenbezeichnungen usw. in

diesem Werk berechtigt auch ohne besondere Kennzeichnung nicht zu der Annahme,

dass solche Namen im Sinne der Warenzeichen- und Markenschutz-Gesetzgebung als frei

zu betrachten wären und daher von jedermann benutzt werden dürften.

Die Informationen in diesem Werk wurden mit Sorgfalt erarbeitet. Dennoch können

Fehler nicht vollständig ausgeschlossen werden und der Verlag, die Autoren oder

Übersetzer übernehmen keine juristische Verantwortung oder irgendeine Haftung für evtl.

verbliebene fehlerhafte Angaben und deren Folgen.

http://www.diplomica.de, Hamburg 2011

Table of Content

Introduction...1

Part A: The Concept of Volunteer Tourism...6

1. Defining Volunteer Tourism and Setting the Context...6

2. Historical Context of Volunteer Tourism...12

3. Volunteer Tourism within other Tourism Segments...14

Part B: Understanding the Volunteer Tourism Market...19

1. The Demand Side: Understanding the Volunteer Tourist...19

1.1 Motivation of Volunteer Tourists...20

1.2 Conceptual Framework of Volunteer Tourists... 28

1.3 Volunteer Tourism: Indicators of a growing demand...28

2. The Supply Side: The Volunteer Tourism Industry...32

2.1 Diversity in Range of Volunteer Projects...33

2.2 Categorizing Core Target Groups...36

2.2.1 Target Group: Individual Customers...36

2.2.2 Target Group: Corporate Customers...42

2.3 Volunteer Tourism Providers: The Volunteer Tourism Industry ...48

2.4 Case Study: Conservation Volunteer Tourism operating from UK...48

3. Volunteer Tourism Program Design and Implementation...54

3.1 Charities Involvement in Volunteer Tourism: Motivation & Benefits...54

3.2 Tour Operators Involvement in Volunteer Tourism: Motivation & Benefits...55

3.3 Incorporating Volunteering: Guidance for Tour Operators...57

3.4 Incorporating Tourism: Guidance for Charities and NGOs...59

3.5 Volunteer Tourism: Platform for Cross-Sector Partnerships...61

3.6 Examples: Volunteer Tourism Models...66

4. Volunteer Tourism: Platform for Sustainable Development? ...71

4.1 Volunteer Tourism and Sustainability... .72

4.2 Volunteer Tourism: Pros, Cons and Possibilities...75

4.3 Volunteer Tourism: Guidelines for Sustainable Development...80

5. Conclusion: Understanding the Volunteer Tourism Market...85

Part C: Volunteer Tourism Market in Germany...91

1. Volunteer Tourism: Review of the German Market...91

2. Hypothesis: Volunteer Tourism in Germany...96

Part D: Future of Volunteer Tourism in Germany: Empirical Part...99

1. Methodology and Research Question...99

2. Summary of Findings: Exploratory Study...100

Outlook: The phenomenon of Volunteer Tourism...105

References...109

Appendix...120

Acknowledgement

The idea for this master's thesis is based on an article, published 2005 in the UK edition of

Newsweek, with the headline "Having fun doing good" which described the phenomenon of

combining holiday and volunteer work as well as the increasing demand for this kind of

holiday. My curiosity was aroused: what motivates people to take up volunteering while on

holiday? Who would want to spend one's vacation time, or at least part of it, as well as money

to travel someplace to do what most consider work?

The wide range of products offered and the diversity of players involved from tour operators to

not-for-profit organizations motivated me to look behind the phrase volunteer tourism in order

to understand not only the concept and potential but also the limitations of the concept as well

as the structure of the market. Furthermore, I questioned why there is such diversity in

volunteer products and players involved in this field in the UK and U.S and why combining

volunteer work and travel is familiar with students in Germany but not very familiar beyond

this target group. The complexity of this topic, the practical relevance as a growing niche

segment as well as the interdisciplinary character of this relatively new research field was

something I found challenging.

First of all, I would like to thank my advisors, Christina Heyniger and Prof. Dr. Wolfgang

Strasdas, for their helpful suggestions starting with the initial thoughts on the topic, discussing

it and helping to delve deeper into this topic. A special thanks to my advisor Christina

Heyniger, Xola Consulting from the USA, who was willing and enthusiastic to support my

thesis and gave me lots of inspiration and insights into the U.S volunteer tourism market

despite the long distance. Her study on adventure tourism and volunteer tourism in

collaboration with the George Washington University, U.S inspired me for my thesis.

I would also like to thank my interviewees for their openness, interest, input and thoughts,

especially Tom Berry, Earthwatch Institute Europe; Sven Mangels, Explore & Help, Fabian

Ritter, Meer e. V.; Julia Neider, WDCS; Kundri Böhmer, Hauser Expeditions; Dina Bauer,

Forum Anders Reisen; Werner Schröder, Nabu, Marina Shakyas, DED, Elke Gernsmann;

Travel Journalist, Anne Schierenberg, Europarc Germany; Felizitas Romeiss Stracke, Future

Reserach; Peter Parwan, Lohas.de; Stephen Wehner, Bergwaldprojekt; Gabriele Wutz,

Timberland; Dr. Matthias Hammer, Biosphere Expeditons, Volker Häring, China by Bike,

Katrin Kohlstädt and Jana Lüth, Goxplore by Gebeco and many more, just to mention a few

that made it possible to gain insights into the topic from both the practical and academic side.

Thanks also goes out to researchers like Nancy McGehee, Sally Brown in the U.S as well as

Stephen Wearing from Australia who helped me and were so kind as to send me articles, which

I could not otherwise have got so easily within Germany.

Introduction

"Voluntouring programs are incredible journeys through remarkable destinations,

combining unique travel opportunities with meaningful volunteer work"

Source: AquilaTours, Canada, www.aquilatours.com

This statement, taken from the website of Aquila Tours, which is one of the first Canadian

tour operators offering this kind of volunteer tourism, shows how this type of tourism is

advertised and sold to the customer as a new kind of travel experience. This example

illustrates how tour operators describe this kind of tourist experience using word games like

"Voluntouring" in order to market this special form of tourism which combines leisure,

volunteer work and travel. This way of spending meaningful holidays is gaining more and

more popularity among vastly different demographic categories of people. To make a

difference while on vacation is already very popular in the U.S, UK and Australia, but is

also a concept that is getting more and more attention worldwide. The media has played an

important role: from The Time Magazine to Forbes Magazine: articles have been devoted

to the idea of blending tourism with community and environmental oriented work (The

Time, 2007:49-51; Forbes, 2006:189-190). Lonely Planet published its first volunteer-

travel guidebook in June 2007 called "Volunteer: A Traveler's Guide to Making a

Difference around the World" as reaction to the growing importance of this travel segment.

Newsweek International (2005) stated in its article: "Having fun doing good: For some

altruistic travelers vacation means more than just a day at the beach", furthermore

describing the phenomenon as follows: "It's tourism with a conscience, undertaken by

travelers who don't want to experience another culture through the windows of a tour bus

(...) ". People are prepared to pay to volunteer and they are even willing to devote holiday

time in order to get actively involved and help in environmental conservation projects as

well as social projects. In Germany, this new type of travel is slowly beginning to be

considered as an emerging trend and was recognised by the press as early as end of 2006

and has been considerably strengthened

since the end of 2007. This phenomenon of

combining holidays with volunteer work has even developed a new term integrating both

aspects: "Voluntourism".

In addition, it has created an industry around this, the so-called

"Voluntourism Industry".

The numbers of socially responsible tourists as well as the opportunities available to them

are increasing. The desire to help is matched by an increasing range of volunteering

Voluntourism.org (2007): A non-profit organization dedicated to the dissemination of information for

travelers and suppliers. Voluntourism.org´s mission is to educate through its quarterly newsletter and global

education opportunities, to empower destinations, operators, supplies and non-profits/NGOs through training

options. There are volunteer tourism experiences offered for singles, students, families and

even retirees, as well as for people searching for a meaningful career break, the "career

gappers". But even companies are supporting their employees by sending them on

corporate volunteering expeditions, known as Corporate Social Responsibility Travel, in

order to help team building processes and to motivate employees.

The diversity of products available reflects the needs of different target groups within this

emerging market. Players in the market consist of for profit organisations ranging from

small tour operators as well as "mainstream tour operators", both of whom are integrating

volunteer activities into their travel products. In March 2007, the holiday giant First

Choice, UK bought I-to-I, one of the biggest companies specialised in what it calls

"meaningful travel", in order to enhance and diversify their product range. Nonprofit

organizations and charities in the environmental or social sector are also becoming

involved in the volunteer tourism sector by integrating tourists into their activities. This

market dynamic is, as of yet, not evident in the German market: the concept is more and

more in the media, but the market structure is not that diverse and has a limited perception

of target groups for combining volunteering and holiday.

But the Volunteer Tourism industry and the volunteers are not only getting praise, they are

also attracting criticism. "Are Volunteer Vacations (...) merely overpriced guilt trips with

an impact as fleeting as the feel good factor? " Or do they offer individuals a real chance

to change the world?" asked The Times in 2007. The booming industry in pre-packaged

volunteer programs is being criticized more and more. Taking into account the broad

spectrum of issues referring to the concept of Volunteer Tourism, this master's thesis has

the following objectives.

Objectives

This master's thesis aims to help understand the global phenomenon of "Volunteer

Tourism" as well as the volunteer tourism market while including the aspect of supply and

demand. For this purpose, the theoretical background as well as the research situation on

this topic has to be reviewed. Although I will primarily focus on the supply side and the

players involved, I will also briefly touch on the demand side as the two cannot be

separated when one wishes to fully analyze the situation. The findings will then be used to

analyze the potential of volunteer tourism in Germany.

Due to the complexity of this topic, this master's thesis cannot provide a comprehensive

coverage of the subject but rather will highlight important aspects and reflect on the

www.trekforceworldwide.com

complexity of the issue. The following sub-research questions will be answered and

discussed and will be a guide throughout this master's thesis on volunteer tourism.

What is behind the phenomenon "voluntourism"?

How do we define it and place it within other tourism segments?

What are volunteer tourists looking for? What is their motivation?

What is the motivation and desired benefit for tour operators and charities to get

involved in this market?

How can volunteering be incorporated into existing tourism products? How can new

and innovative products be designed?

How can uncontrolled growth and development in volunteer tourism be controlled to

ensure sustainable business practices?

! What are the potentials of the concept as well as the limitations?

Where does Germany stand and how will the volunteer tourism market develop there?

! What about the future of volunteer tourism in general? Will this become a global

trend?

And finally: Does the concept of volunteer tourism provide a platform for product

innovations as well as supporting new cross sector partnerships for sustainable

development in tourism?

Structure of the work

The work is divided into four main parts. Part A focuses on the concept of volunteer

tourism. It will introduce the concept by deconstructing this term and delivering definitions

as well as categorizing this segment of travel within other tourism segments while also

looking at the historical background of this phenomenon. This first part will provide the

conceptual framework needed as a basis for the master's thesis and the following chapters.

After setting the context and establishing the theoretical framework in Part A, I will turn

my attention to the complex issue of understanding the volunteer tourism market.

The purpose of Part B is to investigate the volunteer tourism market. Though the focus will

be on the supply side, the aspects of both supply and demand will be taken into account.

The question of volunteer tourism, its sustainability, the opportunities for product

innovations as well as new cross sector partnerships will be discussed. To conclude Part B

"Understanding the Volunteer Tourism Market" the main findings will be summarized and

the research questions connected to this first part of the master's thesis will be answered.

before taking the German Market and its potential into account.

Part C will discuss the current role of volunteer tourism in Germany. From the analysis of

the current situation in Germany, hypothesis will be developed in order to predict the future

of volunteer tourism as a concept and a trend in Germany and how volunteer tourism is

going to develop over time.

In Part D Experts, who cover the range of existing and potential players within the

volunteer tourism industry, as well as stakeholders, are interviewed to further investigate

the German market. As a result, a picture of volunteer tourism in Germany will be

presented. In order to conclude the initial question "

Is the German market ready?" an

outlook of the German market will be given on the basis of the hypothesis and the findings

of the exploratory study conducted for the purpose of considering driving forces as well as

barriers for the concept of volunteer tourism.

Finally an outlook on potentials of the concept of volunteer tourism as well as the

limitations will be provided. Additionally suggestions as well as future research questions

will be formulated due to the remaining gaps in the research in this field.

Methodology

Due to the broad nature of the volunteer tourism phenomenon, a multidisciplinary approach

will be used in order to answer the research questions and to explore this phenomenon from

different perspectives and disciplines including tourism and leisure studies, sociology and

psychology as well as economic studies. In order to set the context and create an

understanding of the concept of volunteer tourism from a theoretical perspective, an

international literature review was done. Due to the popularity of this travel segment in the

UK, U.S as well as Australia, the analysis will mainly be based on literature from and

research conducted in these countries. Due to the fact that research sources on volunteer

tourism have been very limited and fragmented and come mainly from the UK, US and

Australia, this master's is written in English. The choice of this language also takes into

account the fact that volunteer tourism as well as its research community seems to be a

global phenomenon.

Because of the fact that volunteer tourism is a very new research discipline, different

methods of research are applied from secondary research to primary research. Web based

research has had to be added, specifically in regards to the analysis of the supply aspect of

the volunteer tourism market. Travel literature as well as press coverage on the topic were

an important research source as well. Due to the lack of empirical and theoretical

exploration, there was the need to draw on broader tourism literature as well as literature

and research on volunteerism. Various approaches have to be considered along with their

practical applications. Secondary research on both, the supply and demand side, will be

taken into consideration in order to get a complete picture of the volunteer tourism market.

However, the main focus will be on exploring the supply side of this emerging market.

Therefore, no consumer primary research will be provided.

For the German market, an exploratory study with expert interviews on

the basis of semi-

structured questionnaires was conducted in order to forecast the path of volunteer tourism.

This kind of primary research was needed in order to conclude the initial question "Is the

German market ready for the volunteer tourism Market?"

This qualitative study aims to

gain insight into the views and attitudes of experts and stakeholders on the new concept of

volunteer tourism. On the basis of the findings of the exploratory study, conducted for the

purpose of considering driving forces as well as barriers for the concept of volunteer

tourism, an outlook on the German market will be given. This exploratory study aims to

provide a data basis for further research to be conducted for the German market.

One has to take into consideration that this master's thesis is not aiming to provide a global

study on volunteer tourism. Nevertheless, in order to illustrate the diversity of products

offered and organizations providing a volunteer tourism experience, international examples

are used in order to illustrate its diversity as well as to bridge theory with practice.

Part A: The Concept of Volunteer Tourism

In this first part the concept of volunteer tourism will be introduced by deconstructing the

term volunteer tourism, providing definitions and putting volunteer tourism into its

historical context as well as reviewing how it is embedded into other tourism segments.

WHERE

Context

WHO

Characteristics

WHY

Motivation

WHAT

Definition

The objective of this chapter is to provide a theoretical foundation which subsequent

chapters can refer to and build on to form an overall picture that will help to demonstrate

the scope and diversity of volunteer tourism. In order to accomplish this, a literature review

is presented to clarify and analyze this new trend in tourism from a theoretical perspective.

1. Defining Volunteer Tourism and Setting the Context

"To have a holiday and actively contribute to the destination you are visiting."

Source: Go Differently (2007): www.godifferently.com

This short and very simple description of the nature of volunteer tourism taken from the

website of a provider demonstrates the general concept. For marketing purposes, a new

term has been created "Voluntourism", combining both terms: volunteering and tourism.

This term highlights the connection of two worlds that are not usually perceived together.

What is behind the phenomenon of volunteer tourism? What makes it difficult to get closer

to the nature of volunteer tourism is that this interdisciplinary research field has attracted

very little systematic research and no readily agreed upon definition currently exists. There

is a lack of scholarly attention given to volunteering by leisure studies specialists.

Therefore, research on empirical data and on many aspects of volunteer tourism are lacking

within this relatively new research field. Tourism literature has generally neglected the

growing area of this tourism phenomenon. There is obviously a gap between the practical

relevance of this phenomenon as an emerging market and its importance as the subject of

academic research. As Wearing states: "Volunteer tourism has been the subject of selective

pragmatism rather than a specific definition or method (...)" (2001: 1). However, some

literature and research has been published in Australia, the U.S as well as in UK due to the

popularity of this segment of the travel market in these countries.

Compared to the lack of theoretical research on volunteer tourism, there is a huge amount

of media coverage as well as web pages and travel guides to be found. When thinking of

volunteer tourism, one usually has different areas in mind like International Volunteering,

alternative tourism, social work and conservation corps work. Contemporary volunteer

tourism suffered from a lack of differentiation from other forms of tourism or volunteering.

What is missing is the recognition of its more specific identity. Due to the lack of

empirical and theoretical exploration, there was the need to draw on broader tourism

literature as well as literature and research on volunteerism.

The term volunteer tourism has to be deconstructed in order to understand the nature of the

concept combining volunteerism and tourism in order to gain a clearer picture of the

concept. The following section will fill this gap by deconstructing the term volunteer

tourism into its various components and then putting volunteering in the tourism context. In

order to set the context by deconstructing the term volunteer tourism and providing a

theoretical framework, we will start with the definition of the term tourism itself.

Tourism is described as "the activities of persons traveling to and staying in places outside

their usual environment for not more than one consecutive year for leisure, business and

other purposes

" (WTO, 1995: 30).

This definition of tourism has been chosen as a starting point for this chapter because it

takes a slightly broader view of the purpose of tourism. It does not just focus exclusively

on leisure or recreational purposes and therefore offers a platform to integrate other aspects

and purposes of tourism like volunteering while being on vacation.

Volunteer tourism has its roots in "volunteerism", which implies that individuals offer their

service and devote leisure time in order to do something meaningful and participate in

goodwill activities without receiving pay. It is relatively rare in both the study of leisure

and the study of volunteerism and citizen participation to find these two concepts

considered together. The reason for this could be that volunteering is seen "as somewhat

more lofty as (...) the fun and frivolity often associated with leisure" (Henderson, 1984: 58

cited in Stebbins/Graham 2004: 9). Nevertheless, the perception of volunteering has been

broadened by some scientists. Very early Boulding (1973:31 cited in Stebbins/Graham,

2004: 8) theorized that voluntary service borders on leisure, frequently even overlapping it.

Alex Dickson observed that leisure is seen as part of voluntary action and does in fact

"carry this spare-time connotation" (1974:.xiii cited in Stebbins/Graham, 2004:8). As an

example of empirical research, Parker reported findings from research on a group of peace

workers. Even if they worked for the serious cause of peace they considered this work to be

part of their leisure (1987, cited in Stebbins/Graham 2004: 8).

This allows the perception of volunteering as a leisure experience. With an international

assessment "Volunteering as Leisure and Leisure as Volunteering", Stebbins/Graham

(2004) contributed to the leisure perspective of volunteering. This international assessment

provided a perception that has substantial cross cultural validity and applicability. The

perspective that volunteering is a form of serious leisure (Stebbins, 1997) which offers a

distinct set of rewards like self expression and self-actualization that has challenged as well

as relocated researchers in the field of volunteering who are of the opinion "that conceiving

of volunteering as leisure trivializes the former, implying in the extreme case that

volunteers are, at bottom, selfish, unreliable and prone to giving least effort" (Stebbins,

2004:3). In the past, volunteering was more tied to the experience when volunteering was

readily explained as that of unselfish service to the community:

"A volunteer must have some altruistic motive" (...) to be considered a volunteer, altruism

must be the central motive where the reward is intrinsic to the act of volunteering. The

volunteer's motive is a self-less on" (Bussel and Forbes, 2002:248).

Chamber on the other hand defines volunteering as "a work- like activity wherein a person

accomplishes a task without renumeration and at the same time, the activity, which is non-

coercive, provides many a satisfying experience" (1987, cited in Stebbins/Graham, 2004:

9).

Considering both definitions it is clear that even if altruistic associations with volunteering

seem to be dominant when talking about volunteers and their motives, there are a variety

of social and personal rewards available in volunteering. But it has to be taken into account

that perceived stereotypical images of volunteers and ideological assumptions have been

reproduced and continue to colour perceptions about volunteers, preventing them from

being fully understood. To illustrate this, the Britain's volunteering traditions serves as an

example. The altruistic label of respectability that remains attached to volunteering in UK

can be traced back to pre-industrial society. Volunteering activity emerged from the church

and was delivered as acts of selfless duty. During the rise of rapid industrialization and

urbanization, the British Voluntary Sector became a distinct, value laden tradition. The

attitude towards volunteering can still be coloured by stereotypical labels that associate

volunteering with the older middle class community. Britain's more serious volunteering

tradition can be viewed from two perspectives: either as a duty undertaken by privileged

people with leisure time to support worthy causes or alternatively as a pursuit to further

enhance privilege and social status (Kendall and Knapp, 1996 cited in Graham 2004: 16).

As the example of the Britain's volunteering tradition shows and illustrates: preconceptions

and stereotypes have become attached to volunteering thus making it difficult to

conceptualize and define volunteering. The following definition of voluntary action and the

motivation behind it offers an umbrella under which a wide range of volunteer contexts,

like volunteer tourism, fit and allow for new patterns of volunteerism:

"Voluntary action can be explained as acts of active citizenship that provide some form of

benefit to the community without reciprocal financial reward being the primary

motivator"(Graham, 2004: 18).

Volunteerism and its importance in society, even the where, when and why to volunteer, is

constantly changing. It is obvious that volunteering and its perception require a dynamic

approach in order to understand its current role in society. Therefore, we will now look at

changing patterns of volunteerism. The following quotation illustrates the need for a

dynamic approach with respect to volunteerism:

Volunteerism is like a living organism: grows, declines, changes in response to the stimuli

surrounding it. Driving forces and factors are the way we work, the way we view work,

changes in the society in general, changes in the availability of free time, changes in

motivation and attitude, all this has direct effects on volunteering, some patterns are

gaining importance while others fade away"(Arnova, 2005).

A new trend that shifts away from collective volunteerism to individualized volunteerism

as well as away from long-term commitments towards short term, are project based

assignments known as episodic volunteerism. Macduff identified episodic volunteering

almost 18 years ago as "service of short duration", performed on a one time only basis, or

work on a specific project or assignment that reoccurs annually" (Macduff, 1990).

As a newly emerging area of volunteering, we have to mention corporate volunteerism. In

the last 20 years there has been a growth in employee volunteering through, for instance,

workplace programs in the USA. By the 1970´s corporations were using their philanthropy

strategically to form alliances in the community to position themselves as good corporate

citizens. Corporate volunteerism begins in the 1980´s when IBM intentionally linked

philanthropy and volunteerism to its Human Resource Strategies. Corporate volunteering is

one element of the Corporate Social Responsibility strategy with the following benefits for

the company: a better relationship to the community, a better public image, increased

employee retention, better recruiting and the position of a good corporate citizen.

(Kotler/Lee, 2005: 175-185).

Having reviewed some of the emerging styles of volunteerism we have to look into its

developments. Changes in volunteerism development are a result of larger societal shifts as

argued by Hustinx/Lammertyn (2003). In the first half of the century, the reasons for

volunteering were strong social and civic bonds that encouraged and promoted volunteer

commitment. Strong social connections, such as religious and civic associations, fostered

and promoted a form of volunteerism that no longer exists because there is no longer an

emphasis on or tendency towards collective action. Furthermore, Hustinx & Lammertyn

(2003) argue that society's change leads to reflexive volunteerism that is individualized

rather than collective:

"Nowadays, willingness to participate in volunteering seems to be more dependent on personal

interests and needs than on service ethic and a sense of obligation to community. Motivated by a

search for self realization, volunteers demand great freedom of choice and clearly limited

assignments with tangible outcomes. Volunteer activities have to be spectacular and participate for

the sake of belonging to group-bound organizations, but are more pragmatically focused on the

service offered or activities undertaken" (Hustinx/Lammertyn, 2003:168- 17).

As a result, this framework of episodic volunteering and the shift from collective to

individualized volunteerism primarily focuses on personal interests and allows a greater

freedom of choice. While offering limited assignments, it could serve as a framework and

lead the way to explaining volunteer tourism as a newly emerging style of reflexive

volunteerism. The pattern of episodical volunteering is an individual approach to

volunteering that is characterized by limited assignments and more flexibility in

which volunteer activities are built around availability, interests, skills, motivations and

commitment. It provides a platform under which the new style of volunteerism, called

volunteer tourism, fits.

Volunteer tourists do merge volunteerism and travel with the

purpose of creating a unique tourist experience as well as travel in a way which makes a

difference and gives something back to the destination and the community they travel to.

Defining episodic volunteers as those preferring short term volunteering assignments or

tasks, it becomes apparent that specific volunteering opportunities overlap in the perception

of volunteer tourists and episodic volunteers.

While keeping the pattern of episodical volunteering as a sign of change in volunteer

lifestyle in mind, with this theoretical approach of volunteering as a serious leisure

perspective we go a step further, merging volunteerism with travel, thus defining the

phenomenon volunteer tourism as a newly emerging pattern of volunteering. In one of the

first and most comprehensive treatments of volunteer tourism focuses on the volunteer

tourism experience. Wearing (2001) provided a definition on volunteer tourism that

integrates the leisure perspective, the holiday context, as well as the variety of activities in

the field of environmental work, research and community development.

"The term volunteer tourism applies to those tourists who, for various reasons, volunteer

in an organized way to undertake holidays that might involve aiding or alleviating the

material poverty of some groups in society, the restoration of certain environments or

research into aspects of society or environment"(Wearing, 2001: 1).

The volunteer tourist experience is defined as " a direct interactive experience that causes

value change and changed consciousness in the individual which will subsequently

influence lifestyle, while providing forms of community development that are required by

local communities" (Wearing, 2001: p.x). Wearing pointed out that there are various

reasons, not just altruistic motives, why people get actively involved in delivering a service

to the destination:

"They are seeking a tourist experience that is mutually beneficial, that will contribute not

only to their personal development but also positively and directly to the social, natural

and/or economic environments in which they participate."(Wearing, 2001:1).

When referring to the definitions on volunteering mentioned above, an additional aspect

has to be highlighted when referring to contemporary volunteer tourism: These volunteers

not only not receive a financial reward for their voluntary action, volunteer tourists even

have to pay to get this kind of experience and are willing to do that (Singh,2002). After

deconstructing the term volunteer tourism into its components, tourism and volunteerism,

the following definition will highlight the nature of volunteer tourism perceived as a new

kind of tourist experience serving as an add on to the typical holiday experience. The

typical holiday experience is enhanced by integrating a proportion of voluntary service as

an add on to the existing holiday package "as a seamlessly integrated combination of

voluntary service to a destination and the best, traditional elements of travel-arts, culture,

geography and history in that destination."(Voluntourism.org: 2007). This definition

successfully eliminates the contradiction of putting volunteering and tourism together and

adds a key word in its definition: Service. From this point on one can state that Volunteer

tourism can be considered "Service Tourism" (Aabo, 2006:9).

The definition of volunteer tourism provided by Wearing, however, does not differentiate

in age of participants, skills and qualifications needed, level of involvement, duration of

involvement in a project and the extend to which the project focuses on self development

and/or altruistic contribution as the underlying motivational factor. Volunteer tourism is

becoming increasingly ambiguous in definition and context. According to Callanan

/Thomas (2005), it is therefore necessary to deconstruct the concept and include

these factors. A new framework for volunteer tourism was developed that provides a

general conceptualization of the range of volunteer tourism projects and the volunteer

tourists involved. The table below gives an overview of the classification of Volunteer

Projects ranging from category to shallow, intermediate and deep. The shallow volunteer

project promotes the experience to be gained from the trip, offers flexible duration and

short term assignments and does not require specific skills or qualifications. It furthermore

has to be mentioned that the volunteer project itself is promoted as secondary to the

destination.

Table 1: Conceptual framework for Volunteer Tourism projects (Callanan/Thomas: In: Novelli,

2005: 198)

The deep volunteer tourism project, on the other spectrum, seeks individuals with specific

qualifications and skills, actively encourages volunteers to commit to as long a time period

as possible and provides pre-departure training material about the project. The destination

is promoted too, but this is secondary to the information of the project itself. The

intermediate volunteer tourism project is in the middle of this spectrum and focuses on

promoting both the project and the additional travel opportunities available to the volunteer.

These projects focus on the financial support of the project as well as the project's

contribution to the local community or /and environment (Callanan/Thomas 2005: 196-

199). The conceptual framework provided for volunteer tourism projects and the

classification helps to clarify and can be used as the basis for further future primary

research. Having deconstructed the term volunteer tourism within a dynamic environment

and defining the term volunteer tourism within the discussion on new emerging patterns of

volunteerism and new styles of volunteerism, the next chapter will provide an overview of

the historical context of volunteer tourism and the factors that have driven its development.

2. Historical Context of Volunteer Tourism

Tourists wanting to "give back" as an integral part of their vacation experience is not a

completely new concept: tourists have involved themselves in scientific or academic work

projects, donating money to the destination they visit or visiting schools or orphanages

while on tour. But how does one explain this development? If volunteer tourism is not a

totally new concept, what are the roots? The ethics of volunteer tourism reflect a longer

tradition of non-commercial social movement activism also called advocacy tourism

(Pezullo, 2007: see www.voluntourism.org). There are many organizations, especially

environmental organizations that have used tours as a way of providing opportunities to

bear witness and to serve as advocates for environmental and social justice. It is important

to consider that volunteer tourism is not something new or an isolated development, it is a

part of a longer history of grassroots efforts that realize that tourism can do more and draw

people's attention to environmental as well as social issues.

The modern phenomenon of traveling overseas as a volunteer in order to get actively

involved appears to have begun in about 1915 and has involved a variety of organizations

and groups throughout the world.

The Peace Corps, United Nations Volunteers and

Voluntary Service Overseas (UK), just to mention some, have been sending volunteers for

many years as a kind of cross national volunteerism. However, the development of

organizational volunteering and specifically international volunteering has occurred without

it having been considered as a form of tourism (Wearing in Stebbins, 2004: 210).

To consider and understand the current popularity of volunteer tourism, it is obvious that

the media played a key role in promoting volunteerism. The success of international

initiatives like Live Aid provided a new promotional outlet for the voluntary and charity

sectors as well as resulting in an increased and improved image of voluntary work.

(http://www.makepovertyhistory.org). This growing attention offered new opportunities to

charities to promote their cause as well as create new opportunities for motivated people to

get involved (Callahan/Thomas, 2005: 185).

Volunteer tourism is a new style of volunteering, open to a wide range of potential

volunteers, individuals as well as corporations with reference to corporate volunteer

programs. Volunteer tourism is not a new concept but rather is based on the long tradition

of cross national volunteering: what is new is the blending of service oriented activities and

direct hands-on involvement with the traditional tourist diversion (Xola Consulting, 2007).

Contemporary volunteer tourism is new as a growing commercial trend: the marketing term

"Voluntourism" illustrates the mass marketing approach to service. Factors like growth in

volunteer projects, the variety of destinations promoted, diversity in target markets, the type

of players involved, from charities to tour operators as well as the increasing competitive

nature of this sector have facilitated the growth of this sector (Callanan/Thomas,

2005:186).

After deconstructing the term volunteer tourism, examining new emerging patterns of

volunteerism and the historical context of volunteer tourism the next chapter focuses on the

question of how volunteer tourism is embedded into other segments of tourism. How does

one place volunteer tourism within other tourism segments and how can the volunteer

tourism experience be distinguished from the mass tourism experience? Can we draw the

see Gillette, 1968; Clark, 1978, Australian Volunteers Abroad 1989, Beigbeder, 1991; Darby, 1994

line and separate volunteer tourism from mass tourism? These questions will be the focus

of this chapter. Different approaches will be introduced and then put together in order to

understand how the concept of volunteer tourism can be embedded into other tourism

segments.

3. Volunteer tourism within other tourism segments

"Volunteer tourism appears able to offer an alternative direction where profit objectives

are secondary to a more altruistic desire over profit motives in order to assist

communities" (Wearing 2001:12).

As the quotations illustrate Wearing formally categorizes volunteer tourism as a form of

alternative tourism and as an alternative to mass tourism. While defining the volunteer

tourism experience as an alternative to the mass tourism experience, he identifies the

ecotourism element as well as the serious leisure element as interactive elements within the

volunteer tourism experience (Wearing, 2001: 46-50). The following figure provides a

framework in which to locate the volunteer tourism experience as a kind of alternative

tourism experience.

Figure 1 on the following page illustrates the division of tourism into two broad categories:

mass and alternative tourism. The category of alternative tourism is broad and flexible in

order to provide an umbrella for various forms of tourism having one thing in common: all

are to be seen as alternatives to mass tourism considered as conventional, standard and

large scale tourism. Volunteer tourism is defined as a form of alternative tourism that

overlaps with a variety of other alternative tourism segments. Therefore volunteer tourism

could be embedded into other tourism segments like cultural, educational, scientific,

ecotourism, rural tourism as well as adventure tourism. The variety of options and overlaps

do not make it easy to separate it clearly, but it shows the interferences with other niches as

well as the complexity.

Figure 1: Conceptual schema of alternative tourism (Wearing, 2001:30, adapted from Mieczkowski

(1995: 460)

Figure 2 shows that volunteer tourism can also be linked to social tourism and moral

tourism (Butcher, 2003) as well as serious leisure (Stebbins, 1992).

Figure 2: Categorizing volunteer tourism (Callanan/Thomas, 2005:185)

As the next step I would like to analyze the relationship between mass tourism and

alternative tourism in reference to volunteer tourism. Figure 3 helps to understand how

volunteerism, serious leisure and volunteer tourism are embedded in alternative and mass

tourism as well as its overlaps into other tourism segments.

Figure 3: Conceptual schema of alternative tourism and its relationship to ecotourism, serious

leisure and volunteering (Wearing, 2004, in Stebbins/Graham, 2004:211)

With this more integrated approach I will go a step further by introducing the concept of

niche tourism. The concept of niche tourism has emerged in recent years in counter point to

what is commonly referred to as "mass tourism". Referring Novelli "Niche tourism is an

economy of imagination, where individual preferences and practices are coordinated,

packaged and sold" (2005: 4).

The concept of niche tourism, in comparison to the approach to mass tourism, implies a

more sophisticated set of practices that distinguish and differentiate tourists and therefore

the potential to provide this alternative tourism experience. According to Novelli (2005:4)

niche tourism represents diversity and ways of marking differences in a globalised world of

increasing "sameness". For the purpose of this paper I will argue that volunteer tourism

can be analyzed and placed under the umbrella of niche tourism that is viewed as a form of

specialty tourism. By taking into account the consumer's perspective and needs when

looking at the components of the volunteer tourism experience, we are more apt to look at

the concepts from the consumer's perspective which enables us to go beyond the

categorization of mass and alternative tourism that is often coloured with moral

considerations.

As the following Figure 4 shows, the starting point of this analysis is tourism activity and

not the separation of mass and alternative tourism. The term alternative tourism is replaced

by niche tourism which is described as special interest, culture and/or activity based

tourism involving small numbers of tourists in authentic settings. There are a variety of

micro niches, including volunteer tourism emerging from specific tourist's interests. Other

sub-categories belong to these niches. For example: the micro niche environmental tourism

has sub niches like nature and wildlife, ecotourism as well as adventure tourism. One could

argue that there are other ways of categorizing tourism activities under micro tourism

niches.

Figure 4: Niche Tourism Components Novelli (2005: 9)

However, one thing that must be taken into consideration is that these kinds of tourism

niches containing a variety of sub niches demonstrate an alternative tourism development

resulting from the change in consumer's needs and the need of diversification of tourist

products. Callanan; Thomas (2005: 183) argue that volunteer tourism is a major growth

area in contemporary tourism and the consequence of "a restless society, jaded from the

homogeneous nature of traditional tourism products, and seeking alternative tourism

experience". Niche tourism is a growing segment of the tourism industry with a growing

diversity of niche tourism products and services. To come back to our initial question:

Where to place Volunteer Tourism? This chapter showed that in literature, the volunteer

tourism experience is perceived as an alternative tourism experience that overlaps with

other tourism segments. But this separation of mass and alternative tourism bears the

problem of definition and implies the dilemma of value and morale. Therefore we have

chosen the niche marketing approach in order to explain the differences between

conventional and alternative tourism from the consumer's viewpoint. Volunteer tourism is

a niche tourism component and, for the tourism industry, a market to be served. Focusing

on the consumer needs it becomes clear that the niche tourism approach indicates the need

for product innovations and diversification in the tourism industry.

Having examined volunteer tourism within the mass and alternative tourism market and

detecting much interference with rural, ecotourism, cultural tourism and research tourism,

we will now review where volunteer tourism and adventure tourism intersect. The growth

of the adventure travel industry is matched by an increased variety and types of activities

available to consumers. Adventure tourism is an increasingly widespread phenomenon with

no agreed-upon definition. A general consensus regarding a definition of adventure tourism

is lacking, but there are certain activities that clearly fit within the adventure travel

category. Adventure literature has been limited to studies that primarily focus on physical

risks, neglecting the subjective nature of adventure (Sung, Morisson/O´Leary, 1997).

Research has largely focused on physical forms of adventure tourism and leisure, but there

are also non physical types of adventures that are primarily emotional, spiritual and

intellectual and therefore could be perceived as non physical forms of adventure.

Swarbrooke (2003) examined the diversity of adventure tourism based on activities as key

product, pointing out that the picture of what an adventure is has to be broadened to

understand the nature of adventure tourism ranging from physical adventures, like climbing

and trekking but also non physical adventures that are recognized as mental challenges or

emotional adventures under the umbrella of personal growth.

To go more into detail and illustrate this, according to Swarbrooke adventure tourism "

appeals to an expanding proportion of the population who are seeking self- fulfillment and

excitement through participating in physically and mentally stimulating activities, traveling

to remote destinations or engaging in "adrenaline-rush" experiences as part of their

tourist experience" (2003: 55). These activities could range from whale watching to white

water rafting, research expeditions, trekking but also to self discovery holidays or volunteer

holidays perceived as mentally stimulating activity with an opportunity to engage in

cultural exchange, social or environmental work as well as searching for a meaningful,

adventurous holiday experience.

These categories reflect the broad nature of the adventure tourism phenomenon and the

many links it has with other forms of tourism. Adventure tourism clearly overlaps with

other tourism types, but still adventures have a number of distinguishing attributes: they

take risks and thrive from mental or physical challenge, they "seek out stimulation

experiences and they sometimes engage in adventure for personal development or reasons

of self esteem" (Swarbrooke, 2003:57). Adventure tourism's broad nature makes it possible

to put volunteer tourism, as an activity based form of tourism focusing on a non physical

challenge, under the umbrella of adventure tourism.

By setting the context, analyzing and defining the term volunteer tourism and its

components in Part A, the theoretical framework were built in order to provide an

understanding of the diverse and complex nature of the concept of volunteer tourism. Due

to the broad nature of volunteer tourism as well as the lack in research in this area, it was

not easy to systematically explore this new phenomenon. It became clear that volunteer

tourism is not a totally new concept when looking at the historical context and the history

of international volunteering. What are new are new emerging patterns shifting to short

term volunteering opportunities as an integral part of the holiday experience and the shift in

commercialization. Looking at other tourism segments, we found that there are overlaps to

other alternative forms of tourism. Volunteer tourism could be described as a niche

segment in the tourism market that fits under the umbrella of adventure tourism with

reference to adventures of the category of non physical but intellectual and emotional

challenges. Having provided a theoretical framework and a literature review in Part A, we

will go a step further taking into consideration the supply and demand perspective in order

to understand the volunteer tourism market in part B of this master's thesis.

Part B: Understanding the Volunteer Tourism Market

Spending meaningful holidays by combining holiday and volunteer work is becoming more

and more popular among vastly different demographic categories of people. As motivation

plays a major role in the holiday decision and behaviour, the first part of Part B

"Understanding the Volunteer Tourism Market" aims to learn more about the motivational

factors in order to understand the volunteer tourist. The second chapter of Part B will then

focus on the supply side aiming to understand the Volunteer Tourism industry as provider

and "producer" of the volunteer tourism experience and its structure as well as the

players involved.

1. The Demand Side: Understanding the Volunteer Tourist

People are prepared to pay to volunteer and they are even willing to devote holiday time in

order to get actively involved and help in environmental conservation projects as well as

social projects. Why would somebody spend one's vacation time, or at least part of it, as

well as money to travel someplace to do what most consider work? Newsweek

International (2005) stated in its article: "Having fun doing good: For some altruistic

travelers vacation means more than just a day at the beach", furthermore describing the

phenomenon as follows: "It's tourism with a conscience, undertaken by travelers who don't

want to experience another culture through the windows of a tour bus (...). But is it all

about purely altruistic motives or are there other motives to explain the behaviour of

volunteer tourists? What needs do they want to satisfy by adding a volunteer component to

their vacation? How do we differentiate the volunteer tourist from the mainstream tourist?

This question will be answered in order to understand the Volunteer Vacation Tourist. This

chapter aims to provide a conceptual framework of volunteer tourists, based on their

motivations as well as give an outlook at the development of the demand for volunteer

tourism by reviewing surveys as well as changing consumer patterns. Direct or indirect

indicators will be presented in order to predict the future and the growth potential of this

niche travel segment.

It has to be mentioned that no primary research or consumer survey will be provided, as

this is not the focus of the master's thesis. Nevertheless, understanding the supply side of

the volunteer tourism market is not possible without looking deeper into what motivates the

consumer. I will therefore draw on research done in the volunteerism sector as well

as review a selection of motivational models in tourism and the research done, if available,

on the motivation of volunteer tourists. Due to the fact that little research has been done on

the motivation of volunteer tourists, we will try do adapt and transfer findings from

adventure tourist motivation research. It has to be mentioned that volunteers cannot be

considered to be one large, homogenous group, as they are of all ages and diverse

backgrounds: Volunteers are diverse group, active in a wide variety of contexts. This makes

it difficult to understand them and their motives.

1.1. Motivation of Volunteer Tourists

In order to understand the volunteer tourist motivation, I will start with reviewing the prior

research on volunteerism that has been done on volunteers and their motivations in

different contexts. A great deal of work on volunteering has been carried out in the United

States with many studies examining volunteerism in specific organizations or among

particular groups of people.

In order to find out more about the motivational factors of

volunteer tourists, we will first of all look again at one definition on what a volunteer in

general is:

"A volunteer must have some altruistic motive" (...) to be considered a volunteer, altruism

must be the central motive where the reward is intrinsic to the act of volunteering. The

volunteer's motive is a self-less on" (Bussel/Forbes, 2002:248).

The definition above seems to be too narrow, particularly when taking into account our

objective to review what factors do motivate volunteers in the context of holiday volunteer

work. There is evidence that altruism exists in many types of voluntary activity (Unger,

1991 cited in Bussell, Forbes, 2002). But as Cnaan and Goldberg-Glen (1991) demonstrate

as well as an altruistic motive, volunteers tend also to act on egoistical motives. Research in

volunteerism acknowledges that volunteers seek to gain considerable personal benefits,

including self satisfaction and social and personal well being.

Individuals and

organizations volunteer for reasons other than purely altruistic motives (Bussel/Forbes

(2002). Altruism plays an important role but it is more complex. Therefore, it is important

to develop a greater understanding of the motives for volunteerism or the psychological

"functions" (Clary et al., 1999) that volunteering serves.

see Smith, 1994

see Henderson, 1981, 1984

Clary and Snyder (1998) have identified six personal and social functions potentially

served by volunteering by drawing on functional theorizing about the reasons, purposes and

motivations underlying human behaviour. This functionalist research has lead to the

development of a scale, called Volunteer Function Inventory (VFI). The VFI measures

psychological functions associated with volunteering. The six functions which were

identified concerning the generic motivations of volunteerism are the following: Value,

Understanding, Social, Career, Protective, and Enhancement. The following Table 2

describes details the various functions:

Value expression

function

Individuals who volunteer in service do so in order to express values

that are related to altruistic and humanitarian concerns for other

Under-standing

Volunteer

Function

Opportunity for new learning experiences

Social Functions

The relationship the volunteer has with others, Volunteer

experience offers a variety of opportunities for individuals to engage

in an activity being viewed favorable by others

Career Volunteer

Function

Volunteering may also serve the function or satisfies the need of

career related benefits. It may be a means of preparing for a new

career or maintaining skills

Protective

Function

This function is concerned with processes related to the function of

the ego. An individual may volunteer to reduce guilty feelings of

being more fortune than others or confront their own personal

problems

Enhancement

Function

In contrast to the protective function of trying to eliminate negative

feelings related to the volunteers ego , this function is served by a

motivation for the growth of one's ego, through individual personal

development

Table 2: Six Functions: Functionalist perspective to understand volunteers, adapted from Clary,

Snyder, 1998 in Stebbins/Graham, (2004: 90)

This functional framework of volunteerism could be used as basis in order to explore other

meaningful variations of functions or needs being met based on differences in volunteer

activities and settings (Clary et al., 1998). It could be argued that the functionalistic

perspective to understanding volunteers has implications for the understanding of volunteer

tourists. Therefore the functionalist approach could be utilized in research specific to

volunteer tourist experience and provided a theoretical framework. The set of functions

proposed by the functionalist theorist are all relevant to understanding the motivations of

volunteers and the motivation of the volunteer tourists.

When analyzing volunteerism, no matter in which settings and context, one has to bear in

mind that "acts of volunteerism that appear to be quite similar on the surface may reflect

different underlying motivational processes" (Clary et al., 1998, cited in Stebbins 2004,

90). Though different people can engage in activities that on the surface seem similar, they

may be doing so for very different reasons and serving very different psychological

functions with regard to context and setting.

Now we will introduce the Travel Career Ladder Model, based on the Maslow's Hierarchy

of needs, in order to understand tourist motivation and review what implications the model

has on explaining the motivation of volunteer tourists. The ladder is an adaptation of

Maslow's original five fold hierarchical system of human motivation (Maslow, 1976) and

is based on the approach that individuals have a "travel career" in their tourist behaviour.

During their travel career, people seek to satisfy higher level needs or motives through their

holidays.

Figure 5: The travel career ladder, in Swarbrooke, (2003: 68)

There are five motivational levels ranked from low to high-level needs:

concern with biological needs including relaxation

Level of stimulation/ safety and security needs

Relationship development

Self development needs

The theory distinguishes between intrinsic and extrinsic motivations at the four level of the

system. The highest level, fulfillment, is only based on intrinsic motivation and purely self

directed (Pearce, 1996: 13 in Swarbrooke, 2003:68). When we apply this framework to

volunteer tourists, it is evident that the majority would strive to accomplish high level

needs. It is about peak experiences that could lead to dream fulfillment or inner harmony.

These are all motives which can be found at the top of the travel career ladder. Dream

fulfillment could be experienced when combing holiday and volunteering. This kind of

adventures that are non physical, like volunteer adventures, can result in the actualization of

high- level needs. The Travel Career Ladder Model developed by Pearce (1993) provided

an expansive framework to identify the needs that a tourist is fulfilling when traveling. This

model has implications to the analysis of the motivational factors of volunteer tourists.

Now a motivation travel model of volunteer tourists, developed by Brown, will be

introduced to help explain the volunteer tourist's motives. This model is based, similarly to

the travel career ladder model on the Maslow's Hierarchy of needs, but this motivational

model is more a process oriented model (Brown, 2001). Those participating in volunteer

tourism have fulfilled their physiological and safety needs. Volunteer tourists like the idea

of belonging to a group and team-oriented activities. They aspire to fulfill their self esteem.

B = Basics

The basics in someone's life must be fulfilled prior to having the luxury of considering a

vacation on a regular basis. Similar to Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, focusing on life's

basic needs is the main concentration at this level: security, job/career, food, home, health.

R = Relaxation, Rest, and Renewal

On this level of the Brown scale an individual has life's basics under control and they are in

need of rejuvenation. They need to get away and have a change of scenery from their

regular routine. Vacations that encompass the three "Ss", sun, sand, and surf, are often

pursued to meet the needs of this individual. It is bringing life back into balance by taking

a physical and mental rest from every day life.

O = Oneness

At this level an individual is looking for something more than just relaxing. They want to

connect with themselves, family, friends and the world community at large. "Oneness"

brings life balance socially, emotionally, and possibly even spiritually.

W = Wanting

The wanting level is the desire to seek something different. Tourists want to make a

difference and are searching for a meaningful experience and they want to have a new

experience. They want to be more of a "traveler" than just a tourist.

N = Now

The person at this level is not living in the past or dwelling on the future. They are

enriched by living in the present, the "now" state. They don't need a fantasy vacation to

escape reality, but they want to experience the way things truly are in the world. In normal

day-to-day life, one is too busy to appreciate the moment.

It become clear that volunteer tourists seek something different and want to fulfill high

level needs. However, more research is needed in order to understand the decision making

process of volunteer tourists. Step by step I went on further to understand the motives

of volunteerism in the context of holidays providing the functional framework of

volunteerism, the travel career ladder model by Pearce and the Brown Motivational Model.

Now I will review the "push" and "pull" factors as central in motivating tourists. Dann

(1981, cited in Stebbins/Graham 2004: 216)) did motivational research in tourism and

identified "push" and "pull" factors as central in motivating tourists.

"Push factors are motives concerned with the social and psychological status of the

individual while pull factors, on the other hand, are motives aroused by the destination

rather than emerging exclusively from the traveler himself" (Crompton, 1979:410 cited in

Stebbins/Graham, 2004:216).

The theory of push and pull factors illustrates that based on their psychographic

characteristics, push factors are necessarily ranked higher for volunteer tourists than

mainstream tourists. Defining a tourist's motivation using the push and pull model is more

complex when applied to a specific market niche such as volunteer tourists, rather than

mainstream travelers. Internal push motives for volunteer tourists, like discovery,

enlightenment and personal growth, are important but the destination is more than simply a

pull motive to this group. A combination of volunteer tourist needs and the image they

have of the destination creates expectations that a volunteer tourist will have in order to be

satisfied. Kretchmann and Eagles (1990) found that the motivations of, for example,

ecotourists and those of the general tourist differed in relation to intrinsic versus extrinsic

motivation for travel. The general tourist is in most cases liked to feel at home when being

on holiday Volunteer tourists are also attracted by many of the elements that make up a

mainstream tourism experience, namely an attractive holiday destination. Therefore, we

can see similarities but also differences when comparing the importance of pull and push

factors for volunteer tourists on the one hand and mainstream tourists on the other hand.

But the adding of volunteering to the analysis of alternative tourism experience enables us

to differentiate volunteer tourism from forms of mass tourism that are solely focused on

relaxation and excitement. Although relaxation and excitement are of course also

components of alternative tourism experience, the volunteering here is a significant

differentiating component. This provides a strong platform for expanding the

conceptionalization of tourist experience (Wearing in Stebbins, 2004:214).

Details

Seiten
Erscheinungsform: Originalausgabe
Jahr: 2008
ISBN (eBook): 9783842810778
DOI: 10.3239/9783842810778
Dateigröße: 3.5 MB
Sprache: Deutsch
Institution / Hochschule: Fachhochschule Eberswalde – Sustainable Tourism Management, Sustainable Tourism Management
Erscheinungsdatum: 2011 (Februar)
Note: 2,0
Schlagworte: nachhaltiger tourismus sustainable tourism corporate social responsibility tourismusmarketing

Autor

Katja Schluzy (Autor:in)